
Original Coverage & Source Attribution: www.themix.net
Hollywood has seen plenty of behind-the-scenes arguments, but some disagreements have ended with major stars walking away from movies altogether.
From Robert De Niro clashing with a director to John C. Reilly taking a stand over animal treatment, these weren’t ordinary creative differences.
Some actors refused to return, leaving studios scrambling for replacements. Others were fired following heated confrontations. Here are five famous departures that caused trouble on Hollywood movie sets.
Robert De Niro Walked Out of Edge of Darkness After a Reported Shouting Match
Robert De Niro left the set of Edge of Darkness in September 2008, less than a week after arriving to film the thriller alongside Mel Gibson. His representative blamed creative differences with director Martin Campbell.
According to Entertainment Weekly, a source claimed the trouble started when Campbell demanded repeated takes of a golf scene. The disagreement reportedly escalated into a shouting match, although De Niro never publicly confirmed that account.
De Niro didn’t return. Ray Winstone replaced him as Darius Jedburgh, and the film reached theaters in 2010.
James Caan Quit Nailed Over an Argument About a Cookie
A cookie caused a remarkable Hollywood dispute in April 2008. James Caan was filming Nailed, playing a politician who chokes to death, when he disagreed with director David O. Russell over how the scene should work.
Digital Spy reported that Russell wanted Caan to cough while choking. Caan argued that someone couldn’t do both simultaneously.
Russell offered to shoot the scene both ways, but Caan reportedly didn’t trust that his preferred version would be used. He left the South Carolina set and never returned.
James Brolin replaced him. The troubled movie eventually appeared as Accidental Love in 2015.
John C. Reilly Refused to Continue Manderlay After a Donkey Was Killed
John C. Reilly walked off the Swedish set of Manderlay in March 2004 after objecting to the killing of a donkey for a scene in Lars von Trier’s film.
I can understand why this one attracted so much attention. According to The Guardian, the animal was slaughtered for a sequence involving food. Producers defended the decision, claiming the donkey was already due to be slaughtered and that a veterinarian supervised the killing.
Reilly refused to continue and was replaced by Željko Ivanek. He never returned to the movie.
Von Trier eventually removed the controversial footage.
Harvey Keitel Clashed With Stanley Kubrick on Eyes Wide Shut
5
18 Jun 2026. Pictured: Harvey Keitel. Photo credit: Papadakis Press/MEGA
Harvey Keitel’s departure from Eyes Wide Shut became another chapter in Stanley Kubrick‘s reputation for demanding perfection.
During the film’s lengthy production, which began in 1996, Keitel reportedly grew frustrated with Kubrick’s repeated takes. Slashfilm states that Gary Oldman recalled a story about Keitel angrily leaving after filming someone walking through a doorway 68 times.
Keitel later confirmed that he objected to treatment he considered disrespectful, although he described himself as having been fired, rather than walking away.
Either way, he never returned. Sydney Pollack took over his role as Victor Ziegler.
Jean-Claude Van Damme’s Predator Dispute Ended With His Firing
Jean-Claude Van Damme nearly became one of cinema’s most recognizable alien villains. Instead, his brief involvement with the original Predator, filmed in 1986, ended in a disagreement with producer Joel Silver.
Van Damme complained about the uncomfortable creature suit and dangerous stunt requirements. According to SYFY, he recalled refusing a risky jump while wearing the costume, prompting Silver to replace him.
Visual effects supervisor Joel Hynek recalled a heated confrontation between Van Damme and producer Joel Silver over the actor’s desire to use kickboxing moves.
According to Hynek, Silver fired Van Damme during the argument, prompting the actor to angrily storm out. However, other crew members have offered different explanations for his departure.
Kevin Peter Hall eventually played the Predator.