Original Coverage & Source Attribution: decider.com
In Guarding Stars, Netflix adapts Katherine Center’s 2022 romance novel The Bodyguard to fit a Christmastime setting in snowy Montana. Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki star in this tale about a bodyguard and famous actor who stumble into a fake dating scenario while trying to evade a stalker during a family Christmas celebration. With a cast that also includes Andie MacDowell, Noah LaLonde, and Phillip “CM Punk” Brooks, this Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum-directed movie’s earnest performances, entertaining moments, and endearing schmaltz look to make you jolly this holiday season.
The Gist: No-nonsense army veteran Hannah Brooks (Leighton Meester) is a pro at going the extra mile to get the job done as a New York City-based bodyguard. Hannah keeps everyone at arm’s length and dives into work to avoid dealing with the recent loss of her mother. But when her boss Glenn (Greg Lawson) wants her to take a break for the holiday season, Hannah insists she’ll take any job as long as she’s not benched. This leads her to a supposedly in-and-out gig as a ghost protection detail for affable action star Jack Stapleton (Jared Padalecki), to help shake media attention and his persistent stalker while he’s home in High Rivers, Montana, visiting his mother, Connie (Andie MacDowell), in the hospital. But when Jack’s brother, Hank (Noah LaLonde), sees Hannah and Jack arguing in the hallway, Connie and Doc (Shaun Johnston) welcome Hannah in and assume that she is their eldest son’s new girlfriend.
Struggling with Connie’s weakened state and uncertain future in the wake of her tumor removal, Jack goes along with his mother’s assumptions and ends up agreeing to stay on the Stapleton family ranch with Hannah for the holidays. Due to a family tragedy that has left him feeling guilt-ridden for years, Jack has long avoided returning home, putting some inadvertent distance between him and his parents, brother, sister-in-law (Siobhan Williams), niece (Zoe Kosovic), and nephew (Henrik Bosovich). Still, they know him well, making it a tall task for Jack to convince them of his fake relationship with Hannah. With their stay now extended through Christmas, Hannah is covertly joined by her coworkers (Rachael Ancheril, Phil Brooks, and Toby Sandeman) to monitor the situation for external threats. Guarding a star is straightforward enough, but what will Hannah do as Jack and his family start breaking down the long-held defenses of her well-protected heart?
What Movies Will It Remind You Of? Guarding Stars is in a similar vein to other fake dating rom-coms like Holidate, Love Hard, and The Proposal.
Performance Worth Watching: Leighton Meester shines as workaholic bodyguard Hannah Brooks, effortlessly making Hannah feel human and likable by depicting the playful side, strong will, and big heart beneath her serious exterior.
Our Take: Having read The Bodyguard, I think that Netflix made some solid changes to adapt the book into a charming, Montana-set Christmas rom-com. Guarding Stars is in good hands with Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki as the leads, with their decades of combined experience as memorable faces on TV lending well to quickly warming audiences up to their characters and the world they live in. Both actors maintain the ideal balance of earnest and silly needed for this type of movie to succeed, keeping viewers entertained and invested in the process. Their easy chemistry made their characters’ relationship trajectory feel earned and believable, or as believable as a cheesy rom-com can be.
While the movie’s schmaltz can lead to predictable plot points or somewhat melodramatic moments, Guarding Stars is also self-aware enough to call out its own tropes and fully embrace the holiday romance genre. The entire cast commits fully, making things feel generally more sweet and enjoyable than over-the-top or utterly ridiculous. So while this probably isn’t a movie that’s going to reinvent the wheel or become a Christmas classic for the ages, it is going to be a fun, easy viewing experience that offers a satisfying story carried by actors you can trust to deliver reliable performances. All in all, it’s a pleasant Netflix Original that’s worth a watch for anyone who loves anything in the realm of Hallmark holiday movies!
Our Call: With Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki leading the way, Guarding Stars is a charming and pleasantly cheesy movie that will likely satisfy anyone who enjoys a good ol’ holiday rom-com. STREAM IT.
Maddy Casale is a Chicago-based writer and comedian who covers everything from animated series to Hallmark movies. Follow her on Duolingo @MCasale.
